Friday, March 6, 2015

Drones Today = PC's in the Late 80's


I got the drone back up and running.  It turned out that Mission Planner, the PC software that interfaces with the drone, was loading quadcopter firmware with airplane parameters.  It could be that I mistakenly changed a drop down box that selects the default parameter file, or it could be that Mission Planner did not change the parameter file when I reset the drone software from drone to airplane to drone in order to get a "clean load" of drone software (this is the recommended method for resetting your APM/Pixhawk software).

In reflecting on all the hours spent debugging the problem, and the difficulty in identifying the problem, I think the "Drone Industry" is about where PCs were in the late 80's.  It is not a perfect comparison, but it is reasonably close, check out my table below:

CharacteristicDrones TodayLate 80's PCsPCs Today
Off The Shelf Complete UnitsYes (DJI, 3DR..), but many complaints about the white label productsYes (IBM PC, Apple MAC..), but many complaints about the white label productsAlmost all PCs bought off the shelf and work 1st time
HardwareSomewhat standardized, but incompatibilities are commonStandardized, but incompatibilities are commonPlug and Play for almost all hardware
SoftwareLots of variations, nice user interface over a command line operating system, lots of variables to customize, many bugsA few variations, nice user interface (Windows) over a command line operating system (DOS), lots of variables to customize, a few bugsA few variations, nice user interface (Win or OSX), a few variables to customize with wizards to help, few bugs
Growth RateVery highVery highShrinking as people use more mobile devices
Industry ParticipantsAll small companies (DJI, 3DR, Turnigy..), no leaderIBM, Apple, and Compaq are leaders, many small players as well (Packard Bell, Nortel, ..)A small number of huge well known companies: Apple, HP, Lenovo..

Photo credit: Flickr

No comments:

Post a Comment